The choice between a Weber kettle and the Smokey Mountain depends on your specific cooking needs. The Weber kettle is versatile and ideal for both grilling and basic smoking tasks, suitable for quick meals and searing. On the other hand, the Smokey Mountain is specifically designed for smoking, offering superior temperature control and the ability to maintain low, slow heat for extended periods. If you are passionate about smoking and looking for a dedicated smoker, the Smokey Mountain is the better choice.